Andaz vs Four Seasons Maui: Which Is Best For You?

If you’re planning on staying in Wailea, you have a many amazing resorts to between for your stay.

The Four Seasons Maui is one of the best known hotels on the island, attracting clientele from all over the world to stay in their elegant suites.

The Andaz is a bit of a newcomer in comparison, but it’s quickly established a reputation as a chic place to be. With contemporary rooms and a private location, the Andaz offers its own type of luxury.

Which resort is best for you?

When Were The Resorts Opened?

The Four Seasons Maui was opened in 1990, and was one of the first resorts to establish itself in Wailea. Since then, it’s undergone renovations to keep the rooms up to standard, and competitive with other luxury resorts in the area.

The Andaz is a relative newcomer to the Wailea area, having opened its doors in 2013.

What Are The Rooms Like In The Andaz And The Four Seasons Maui?

The Andaz Maui:

The rooms at the Andaz Maui use modern designs to create a comfortable living space.

Andaz Maui’s rooms are tasteful, with 380 to 420 square feet of space, wide windows to let in the light, and a neutral color palette.

Enjoy a private lanai, rainfall showers, and a spacious sleeping area.

If you fancy something a little larger, the suites follow the same principles as the guest rooms. Designs are refined and tasteful, and appealing to a forward-thinking clientele.

For really spreading out, the villas at the Andaz Maui are ideal. Groups and families will find themselves immediately comfortable in the modern villas.

The Four Seasons Maui:

Elegance is also on show at the Four Seasons, although on a bigger scale. Literally. Even a standard room at the Four Seasons has 600 square feet of space to move about in.

The Four Seasons Maui uses a simplified color scheme and natural materials to create rooms that are classical and elegant. Amenities are abundant, and there’s plenty of space in even the smallest guest rooms.

The real star of each room, however, is the luxurious marble bathroom. It elevates the Four Seasons, with an impeccable finish adding even more class to the fantastic fittings.

There are a rich variety of rooms available at the Four Seasons, including suites large enough for bigger families.

Can You Rent A Suite Or Villa At Andaz Or Four Seasons Maui?

You’re in luck if you want a Maui stay with more in the way of home comforts: both Andaz Maui and the Four Seasons have suites available for rent.

The Four Seasons has small suites, large suites, and premium suites, so you have plenty of choice when it comes to space. The largest of the large suites is an impressive 7,200 square feet, while a small suite is a comparatively petite 840.

Whereas Andaz Maui suites are on the small side, with the majority being 850 square feet. If you want something bigger, either book one of the two premier suites in advance, or consider one of the spacious villas.

Which Has The Best Pools, Andaz Maui Or The Four Seasons?

No trip to Maui is complete without at least one dip in the pool.

Andaz Infinity Pools

At the Andaz, the four-story infinity pool is the crowning jewel, a sleek and modern design. One level is adults-only access.

Four Seasons Fountain Pool

With a sprawling design centered around a breathtaking fountain, the Four Seasons fountain pool is for everyone. Swaying palm trees and an ocean backdrop also makes it a great photo opportunity.

Four Seasons Waterfall Pool

Tumbling waterfalls provide the fun at the family-friendly Four Seasons waterfall pool. Expect crowds, but the sounds of running water add an unexpected peace for parents.

Four Seasons Serenity Pool

Get away from it all at the adults-only serenity pool. The Four Seasons serenity pool is for those 21 plus only, making it a great place to escape the crowds.

What Are The Restaurants Like At The Andaz And The Four Seasons?

The Andaz and the Four Seasons both have celebrity chef designed restaurants on premises, alongside more casual dining. Head to Andaz for Iron Chef Masaharu Morimoto’s sushi, or the Four Seasons for Wolfgang Puck’s fusion experience.

Dining At The Andaz Maui

There’s a real variety to dining at the Andaz, with Morimoto Maui being the top choice for discerning diners. Ka’ana Kitchen provides family meals, while Bumbye Beach Bar serves delicious cocktails and Hawaiian lunches.

Dining At The Four Seasons Maui

Although there are several dining options at the Four Seasons, the most impressive is definitely Wolfgang Puck’s Spago. The menu blends Hawaiian ingredients and California cuisine, creating something both modern and traditional.

Which Has The Better Maui Spa, The Andaz Or The Four Seasons?

Relaxation in Wailea comes easy, but a trip to the spa certainly isn’t unwelcome. A luxurious spa is available at both the Andaz and the Four Seasons.

‘Awili Spa And Salon At The Andaz

A visit to the ‘Awili Spa and Salon at the Andaz is a unique experience. With the treatments personalized to you, every guest can be assured they’re getting the best service possible. An apothecary spin really sets the Andaz spa apart, as do the sleek and attractive rooms.

The Four Seasons Spa

The spa at the Four Seasons is well known for the incredible level of service provided, and the range of treatments on offer. Using state-of-the-art spa equipment and the latest in relaxation and rejuvenation techniques, a session at the Four Seasons spa is a real treat.

What Restaurants Are On-Site At Andaz Maui And Four Seasons Maui?

Foodies will find some incredible options at both Andaz Maui and the Four Seasons.

Four Seasons is home to Spago, the Hawaiian outpost of Wolfgang Puck. Serving a fusion of flavors from Hawaii and California, this is the spot for fresh and exciting cuisine.

Fans of innovative celebrity chefs will also be happy at Andaz, where Morimoto Maui serves up spectacular sushi.

The Four Seasons also houses Duo, for lovers of steak and seafood, and Ferraro’s Bar E Ristorante, one of the most romantic spots on Maui.

But there’s no lack of options at Andaz Maui either. Ka’ana Kitchen serves farm-to-table local delicacies family style, while Lehua Lounge presents an elevated take on traditional bar snacks.

Andaz Maui also has its own on-site luau! Feast at Mokapu is a luxury take on the luau, serving quality food alongside incredible entertainment.

What Does The Andaz Maui Do Best?

The Andaz Maui is family friendly, but the contemporary design is best suited for couples, like honeymooners. The infinity pool is an attractive and unusual feature, and the sushi at Morimoto is an ideal date-night meal. The rooms use sleek forms and simple colors to create a space that really is cool.

Andaz Maui is situated by Mokapu beach, which is slightly quieter than the popular Wailea beach. The waves are ideal for snorkeling, and the views across to Molokini are outstanding.

What Does The Four Seasons Maui Do Best?

Luxury may be standard at the Four Seasons, but it also caters well to families. The large pools are fun and friendly, and the variety on offer allows all visitors to create the perfect vacation experience.

The Four Seasons has a prime location on Wailea beach, one of the most popular beaches on Maui. With soft sand and plenty of activities, families and adventures will enjoy having this on their doorstep.

Which Is Best For You?

In a place like Wailea, it’s hard to go wrong. Both the Four Seasons and the Andaz Maui are fantastic resorts.

Choose the Andaz if you want laid-back chic. The modern resort is good for families, and fantastic for couples looking for some privacy.

The Four Seasons does greater luxury, and appeals to everyone from families to business travelers.


Other Places To Stay In Maui

We’ve written quite a bit about all of Maui’s available lodging, and continue to do so, but we wanted to share a few more places to stay from our friends at 

A Resort Stay: The Four Seasons Resort in Wailea is the cream of the crop of resort stays, with restaurants, ocean views, an on-site spa, and the Shops at Wailea are just down the road. Couples particularly love The Four Seasons!

Bed and Breakfast: Sometimes, it’s all in a name, and Adventure in Paradise is exactly what it sounds like, located in Haiku on Maui’s north shore. Wake up to a 180 degree view of Haleakala summit every morning from your private patio.

Hotel: The highly rated Maui Sunset hotel combines laid-back atmosphere and the beach of Waipuilani Park. Also, it’s only 1.7 miles from the Elleair Maui Gold Club!

Vacation Home: Find your home away from home at Puu Koa Palms, six minutes from Hookipa Beach, and near the Hana Highway. Also particularly great for couples!

Villas: If you’re looking to vacation in style with your own villa try the Andaz Maui, which include all the expected amenities along with grills and plunge pools.

Scroll to Top